Despite Real Madrid’s loss to Valencia, the spotlight has shifted from the scoreboard to a fiery VAR controversy that has reignited criticism over video refereeing in Spain. At the center of it all? A penalty awarded to Kylian Mbappé after contact from Valencia’s César Tárrega.
What Happened?
In the second half, Mbappé went down in the box after a challenge from Tárrega. Referee Cuadra Fernández had no hesitation in pointing to the spot. But as per protocol, VAR stepped in, with Figueroa Vázquez inviting the on-field referee to review the footage.
The leaked VAR audio has caused a stir:
“I recommend you come to see the play so that it won’t be a penalty,” Figueroa Vázquez told Cuadra Fernández.
The phrasing, suggesting a preconceived conclusion, didn’t sit well with fans—especially given how delicate decisions like this are supposed to be based on objective review, not suggestions.
Referee Stands Firm
Despite the VAR’s recommendation, Cuadra Fernández stood by his call after rewatching the play:
“There is the touch that unbalances Kylian in the ball dispute. That player’s touch is what knocks him down… I maintain the decision, I go with a penalty.”
So, the penalty stood—but the drama didn’t end there.
Vinícius Misses – And Faces the Wrath
Vinícius Jr. stepped up, but missed the penalty, triggering boos from the home fans. The Brazilian’s inconsistent form in 2025 has already placed him under scrutiny, and the miss only worsened his situation, leading to visible frustration and what some describe as a “divorce” with the Bernabéu crowd.
The Bigger Picture
The controversy has now sparked fresh debates:
• Should VAR “recommend” or “present” replays without opinion?
• Was Cuadra Fernández right to ignore the suggestion?
• Who should be Real Madrid’s penalty taker moving forward?
More than just a single match decision, this incident highlights ongoing concerns over VAR communication, referee autonomy, and the need for transparent, unbiased decision-making.
And with Real Madrid chasing silverware, tensions like this could have major consequences in the weeks ahead.
