A campaign to push a Palestinian lullaby to the top of the UK Christmas charts has erupted into open controversy, exposing deep divisions over politics, music, and the meaning of Christmas itself. The song, Lullaby, released by the Together for Palestine fund, aims to raise money for aid in Gaza while foregrounding Palestinian culture. What might otherwise have been a charitable music release has instead become a lightning rod for public anger, online disputes, and accusations of politicising a national tradition.
Brian Eno’s involvement has amplified the reaction. By openly urging listeners to help propel the track to Christmas number one, Eno has drawn criticism from those who see the move as an attempt to hijack a culturally symbolic chart position for political messaging. Supporters argue that Christmas has long been a moment for compassion and solidarity, while opponents insist that the campaign crosses a line by turning a festive chart battle into a statement on an ongoing geopolitical conflict.
At the heart of the song is Palestinian singer Nai Barghouti, who performs an adaptation of the traditional lullaby Yamma Mwel El Hawa. Barghouti has described the song as a declaration of dignity and resistance, centered on the idea that life without freedom is unacceptable. This framing has further inflamed debate, with critics claiming the lyrics present a one-sided narrative, while advocates argue that Palestinian voices are routinely marginalized and deserve visibility on a mainstream platform.
The track was recorded after the Together for Palestine concert at Wembley Arena in September, an event that brought together 69 artists, speakers, and activists and raised £2 million. Although Lullaby was originally intended to be performed live at the concert, it was cut due to time overruns. The final recording features a large roster of well-known artists, a detail that has fueled accusations that celebrity influence is being leveraged to push a contentious message into the charts under the banner of charity.
Produced by Kieran Brunt with Benji B and Henri Davies, and combining Arabic lyrics with English words written by Peter Gabriel, Lullaby now stands as more than a song. With proceeds going to Palestinian causes via the Choose Love charity, the release has become a cultural flashpoint, prompting heated arguments over whether art should challenge the status quo or remain separate from political advocacy—especially during the most commercially and emotionally charged week of the UK music calendar.
About the Author
